On this page
You need a new website when it fails on a phone (slow, no tap-to-call button, tiny text), when it can't be updated without paying someone, when one page tries to cover every service and town, when form leads go missing, or when you don't control the domain and logins. One or two small problems can be patched. Four or more is a good reason to price a rebuild against the cost of fixing each one.
Key takeaways
- Test your site on your own phone, on cell data, standing in a driveway.
- If you can't change your hours or a price yourself, the site is working against you.
- Every service you want more of deserves its own page.
- Check who owns the domain before anything else; it's the hardest thing to recover.
- Count the signs: a few can be patched; many mean it is time to price a rebuild.
Most contractor websites don't fail all at once. They get a little more out of date each year until the site is costing calls instead of bringing them in. Go through this list with your own site open on your phone. Each sign says what to check, why it matters, and whether it can be fixed without starting over. For what a good site should have, see our page-by-page guide to what a contractor website needs.
1. It takes more than a few seconds to load on cell data
Your customers look you up from a parking lot, a basement with a leaking pipe, or a couch with weak Wi-Fi. If the page sits blank, some of them hit back and call the next result. Google's page experience documentation says Core Web Vitals are used by its ranking systems and recommends that site owners achieve good scores. The same page is clear that good scores don't guarantee your pages will rank at the top, so treat speed as a customer problem first.
Check: turn off Wi-Fi, load your home page, and count. Then run it through PageSpeed Insights and look at the mobile result. Huge uncompressed photos and page-builder bloat are common causes.
2. There is no call button you can reach with your thumb
On a phone, the most valuable action on your site is a tap that dials you. If the number is an image, sits only in the footer, or isn't a tap-to-call link, you are making a ready buyer copy digits by hand.
Check: open the site on a phone and try to call you from the top of three different pages. You should never have to scroll or zoom to find the number. A sticky call and text bar at the bottom of the screen fixes this on many sites, and if every page needs it added by hand, that is a sign of a deeper problem.
3. You can't change hours, prices or photos without calling someone
A site you can't update drifts out of date. Your winter hours stay up in July, last year's price range stays up after a price increase, and the "new" photos are from three trucks ago. Every one of those mismatches makes a customer trust you a little less.
Check: time how long it takes to change one sentence on your services page. If the answer is "I send an email and wait a week", either get edit access or plan a site where the facts you change most often (hours, prices, service areas, team) live in one place you control.
4. One page lists every service you offer
A single "Services" page with eight bullet points can't answer the questions behind each job. Someone searching for gutter cleaning wants to know whether you remove the debris, whether you check the downspouts, and what it roughly costs. A bullet that says "Gutter cleaning" answers none of that, and it gives search engines almost nothing to match.
Check: list the three services that make you the most money. Each needs its own page with what's included, what affects price, photos of that work, and a call button. If your platform makes adding a page painful, that's a rebuild sign.
5. It never says which towns you serve
Homeowners want to know before they call whether you come to their street. A site that only says "serving the greater metro area" makes them guess. It also gives search engines less to match when someone searches with a town name.
Check: search your site for the names of your five best towns. They should appear in your service area section and, where you have real work to show there, on dedicated service-area pages with details specific to that town. Copying one page fifty times with the town name swapped is not the answer.
6. Quote requests go missing
A contact form that emails an address nobody checks, lands in spam, or quietly broke during a plugin update can be the most expensive sign on this list, because you never see the leads you lost.
Check: fill out your own form today with a test name and a real cell number. Time how long it takes to reach a person who can call back. Better sites send each request straight into your CRM, text the office, and send the customer an instant confirmation, so nothing depends on one inbox.
7. Someone else owns your domain name
If your web designer or an old marketing company registered the domain in their name, they control your address on the internet. ICANN's registrant benefits and responsibilities page puts the duty to keep accurate registration details on the registrant, and says the registrant assumes sole responsibility for the registration and use of the domain name. The registrant is the person or company listed, and that may not be you.
Check: log in to the registrar yourself. If you can't, or the registrant listed is a vendor, move the domain into an account under your company's name before you change anything else. Our guide to buying a domain name for your business shows how a clean registration should look.
8. Browsers mark it "Not secure"
If your site still loads without HTTPS, Chrome tells visitors that the site doesn't use a private connection and that someone may be able to view and change the information they send and get through it, as described on Chrome's help page. The same page says the fix is for the site owner to secure the site with HTTPS. That is a bad message to show right above a form asking for someone's address and phone number.
Check: look at the address bar on desktop and mobile. Many hosts include a certificate with the plan. If yours can't, or the fix keeps breaking, the hosting is part of the problem.
9. The photos are stock images or are years old
A homeowner choosing between three companies looks for proof you do this work around here. Stock photos of a model in a spotless hard hat prove nothing. Photos of your trucks, your crew and finished jobs in recognizable local housing styles do.
Check: count the photos on your site that came from your own phone. If it's fewer than half, start collecting before and after shots on every job now, so the new site has real material to launch with.
10. You can't tell which calls came from the site
If you don't know how many calls and form fills the website produced last month, you can't judge whether it's working or compare it to what you spend on ads and marketplaces.
Check: ask whoever runs the site for last month's calls, form submissions and their sources. If the answer is a traffic chart with no leads on it, you need analytics events on calls and forms, plus a way to tell website calls apart from your other calls. Our lead source tracking guide lays out a simple setup.
11. It still lists services, staff or prices you dropped
A customer who calls for a service you stopped offering two years ago is annoyed, and so is your office. Old team photos and a copyright line from years back tell people nobody minds the store.
Check: read every page once, top to bottom, as a customer would. Write down anything wrong. If the list is long and spread across many pages, a rebuild with a short, accurate site often beats patching each line.
12. Some visitors can't use it at all
Low-contrast gray text, images with no text description, and forms that can't be filled out with a keyboard lock out customers with disabilities, and plenty of older homeowners struggle with them too. The Department of Justice's March 2022 guidance on web accessibility says the Department has consistently taken the position that the ADA's requirements apply to the goods and services that businesses open to the public offer on the web, and it gives color contrast, alt text, video captions, form labels and keyboard navigation as examples of what to get right. Whether and how the ADA applies to your business is a legal question, so treat this as general information, not legal advice.
Check: try to complete your quote form using only the Tab and Enter keys. If you get stuck, so do some of your customers.
13. Your site lives on a platform you can't leave
Some website deals bundle the site into a monthly plan where the design, the pages and sometimes the domain stay with the vendor if you cancel. You've paid for years and own nothing you could move.
Check: ask your provider in writing: if I cancel, what do I get? The reply should list the domain, your written content, every image, and a working copy of the site or its files. If it doesn't, plan your exit. Read our builder versus custom site comparison to see what you keep with each.
14. Your office answers the same questions all day
"Do you service my town?" "Do I need to be home?" "Roughly what does it cost?" If your office answers these on most calls, the website isn't doing its job. A good site answers them before the phone rings, so the calls you get are from people ready to book.
Check: ask whoever answers your phone to write down the five questions they hear most this week. Each one should be answered clearly on the relevant service page and in a short FAQ.
Where to start
Count how many signs you checked off. One to three can usually be fixed on the site you have. Four or more, especially if item 3 or item 13 is among them, is a strong reason to get a rebuild quote and compare it with the cost of fixing each problem on the old site. Either way, do these three first:
- Secure the domain (item 7). It's the one asset that's hard to get back.
- Test your own form and call button (items 2 and 6). Lost leads cost money every day.
- Fix speed on mobile (item 1). It affects every visitor and every page.
When you're ready to rebuild, our website service builds sites you own outright, and the free system quote will tell you which of these fourteen signs apply to your site.
Frequently asked questions
How often should a contractor rebuild their website?
There's no fixed schedule. Rebuild when the site can't be updated easily, fails on phones, or no longer matches the services and towns you sell. A well-built site with regular content updates can last many years.
Can I fix a slow website without rebuilding it?
Often, yes. Compressing images, removing unused plugins and moving to better hosting fix many slow sites. If the slowness comes from the theme or page builder itself, a rebuild is usually the cleaner fix.
Will a new website hurt my Google rankings?
It can if old page addresses disappear. Google's site-move guidance recommends mapping each old URL to its new page with permanent redirects, such as 301 or 308, and keeping them as long as possible, generally at least a year.
Should I own my domain name even if an agency manages the site?
Yes. Put the domain registration under your company's name, in a registrar account you control, and give the agency access as needed.
Sources
- Google Search Central: Understanding page experience in Google Search results
- ICANN: Registrant benefits and responsibilities
- Google Chrome Help: Check if a site's connection is secure
- U.S. Department of Justice: Guidance on web accessibility and the ADA, March 2022
- Google Search Central: Site moves with URL changes
General information for service-business owners, not legal, tax or financial advice. Rules vary by state; check with a qualified professional for your situation.